Scientific American, March 2012 -- "Blocking HIV's Attack," Carl June & Bruce Levine
In 2009, many headlines were grabbed by a medical story in which a man--the so-called "Berlin Patient"-- was cured of HIV after receiving a bone marrow transplant. June and Levine explain this case, and why we're still not entirely sure what exactly happened, and elaborate on the work that they and others have done to conceptually follow up on this treatment angle.
HIV reproduces by hijacking the body's immune system, invading T cells and using their cellular machinery to make copies. But some people are lucky enough to be completely resistant to HIV, not showing signs of infection despite repeated exposures. It turns out that this is because of a genetic mutation that disables the CCR5 protein from being expressed on T cell membranes. Without this protein, HIV lacks an entry point into the T cells, eliminating its reproductive pathway. The Berlin Patient was a man who had both HIV and lymphoma, and so was a candidate for a bone marrow transplant. This involves killing off his existing bone marrow with radiation and then injecting donor bone marrow (which must be a close enough genetic match that the body will accept and use it). In this case, the bone marrow was selected to be from a donor who also happened to have the rare genetic mutation leading to an absence of CCR5 protein, and this seems to be what led to the elimination (possibly) of HIV from the recipient's system. This is all tentative, unfortunately, due to the fact that we can't be sure whether the HIV has been eliminated, or is just hiding somewhere we can't find it, that other aspects of the treatment (such as radiation) could have killed off or reduced the HIV, and that this match was such a statistical rarity that a replication is very hard to produce.
However, it may be possible to artificially cripple the CCR5-coding portion of the genetic code, resulting in gene therapy wherein the patient's own genetic material is extracted, altered, and reintroduced. This might be a much more efficient, and safer, way of achieving the same sort of results.
Tuesday, May 29, 2012
TL;DR - Saving Energy for Later
Scientific American, March 2012 -- "Gather the Wind," Davide Castelvecchi
Renewable energy is definitely the future, but there are still many problems to be worked out before it can take over from fossil fuels. One major concern is the reliability of energy sources; what happens when the wind calms, or the sun goes down? Modern energy usage demands consistency, which renewables often lack. Storing energy for later is the obvious way around this, and Castelvecchi reviews five different proposed solutions, each receiving ratings from an expert panel on measures of scalability, cost-effectiveness, and efficiency.
Pumped hydro (pumping water uphill for potential energy) and compressed air (pumping air into rock formations and caverns for later extraction) are two methods that are currently in use, and which show significant promise, though certain limitations, such as geological and geographical considerations, hinder their large-scale deployment. Battery technology is advancing strongly, as well, though it will inevitably be costly. I'd heard about thermal storage--storing heat in molten salt--before, though it, too has some technological hurdles to jump. Finally, home hydrogen conversion (using small-scale systems to break down water into hydrogen at off-peak rates) is an interesting idea, though it is the one that has furthest to go before it's a practical solution.
Renewable energy is definitely the future, but there are still many problems to be worked out before it can take over from fossil fuels. One major concern is the reliability of energy sources; what happens when the wind calms, or the sun goes down? Modern energy usage demands consistency, which renewables often lack. Storing energy for later is the obvious way around this, and Castelvecchi reviews five different proposed solutions, each receiving ratings from an expert panel on measures of scalability, cost-effectiveness, and efficiency.
Pumped hydro (pumping water uphill for potential energy) and compressed air (pumping air into rock formations and caverns for later extraction) are two methods that are currently in use, and which show significant promise, though certain limitations, such as geological and geographical considerations, hinder their large-scale deployment. Battery technology is advancing strongly, as well, though it will inevitably be costly. I'd heard about thermal storage--storing heat in molten salt--before, though it, too has some technological hurdles to jump. Finally, home hydrogen conversion (using small-scale systems to break down water into hydrogen at off-peak rates) is an interesting idea, though it is the one that has furthest to go before it's a practical solution.
TL;DR - The Giants of Utah
Scientific American, March 2012 -- "Dinosaurs of the Lost Continent," Scott Sampson
Sampson details paleontological work that he and others have done in western North America, stretching from Alberta to Mexico, that suggests that in the Cretaceous era there were multiple (~ 17-20) species of giant (>1 ton) dinosaurs cohabitating. Why this is surprising is because at the time, these dinosaurs were sharing a continent--Laramidia--that was significantly smaller than present-day North America, and which, based on understandings of current species, should have been too small to sustain that number of species. As a comparison, current-day Africa is only able to sustain about 6 giant species. Two main theories have been advanced to explain this: either the dinos were much more efficient than present-day mammals (possibly being cold-blooded, or maybe lukewarm-blooded), or the flora of the time was much more productive (the climate would have supported a hothouse environment at mid latitudes).
Sampson details paleontological work that he and others have done in western North America, stretching from Alberta to Mexico, that suggests that in the Cretaceous era there were multiple (~ 17-20) species of giant (>1 ton) dinosaurs cohabitating. Why this is surprising is because at the time, these dinosaurs were sharing a continent--Laramidia--that was significantly smaller than present-day North America, and which, based on understandings of current species, should have been too small to sustain that number of species. As a comparison, current-day Africa is only able to sustain about 6 giant species. Two main theories have been advanced to explain this: either the dinos were much more efficient than present-day mammals (possibly being cold-blooded, or maybe lukewarm-blooded), or the flora of the time was much more productive (the climate would have supported a hothouse environment at mid latitudes).
TL;DR - To The Ends of the Universe
Scientific American, March 2012 -- "The Far, Far Future of Stars," Donald Goldsmith
The universe had a beginning, and will, ultimately, have an end (...probably). Fortunately we're living somewhere in the middle, because this is where it gets exciting. Goldsmith describes theoretical predictions and models of how the universe will develop over the coming billions and trillions of years, in which we'll see (okay, we probably won't be around, but maybe someone will see) a dramatic decrease in the rate of star formation. Yet as stars mature, the rate of production of heavy elements will ramp up, which will ultimately fuel an increase in planetary formation--Goldsmith claims that 1/2 to 2/3rds of the planets that will ever exist have not yet been created. With many more planets, despite the fact that they will in general be orbiting weaker suns, there will be many more chances for appropriate conditions for fostering life to arise. So before we get to the predicted "not with a bang, but with a whimper" slow heat death of the universe, it may become a much more lively place.
TL;DR - Jumping Genes in the Brain
Scientific American, March 2012 -- "What Makes Each Brain Unique?", Fred Gage & Alysson Muotri
Gage and Muotri describe mobile elements, or "jumping genes," short genetic segments that are able to be cut/copied and reinserted into DNA. This can have several possible effects on the genetic code, introducing amino acid substitutions, repeats, or stops in coding regions, changing a given protein, or altering noncoding regulatory region, changing how much a given protein is expressed.
Mobile elements are active only in reproducing cells, meaning their effects are often seen in the gonads, but they're also particularly active in the brain at sites of neurogenesis, such as the hippocampus. Gage and Muotri (or the editors) play up this element to argue that these genetic differences are what contribute brain differences, even in identical twins. I think this is a bit of an overstatement on their part, however. The environment, or the unique experiences a person has, has direct and continuing effects on the development of the brain. As such, mobile elements can help explain how this process occurs, and why the effects of even the same environment can differ among individuals (especially given the random nature of mobile elements), but it's only a part of the picture.
Gage and Muotri describe mobile elements, or "jumping genes," short genetic segments that are able to be cut/copied and reinserted into DNA. This can have several possible effects on the genetic code, introducing amino acid substitutions, repeats, or stops in coding regions, changing a given protein, or altering noncoding regulatory region, changing how much a given protein is expressed.
Mobile elements are active only in reproducing cells, meaning their effects are often seen in the gonads, but they're also particularly active in the brain at sites of neurogenesis, such as the hippocampus. Gage and Muotri (or the editors) play up this element to argue that these genetic differences are what contribute brain differences, even in identical twins. I think this is a bit of an overstatement on their part, however. The environment, or the unique experiences a person has, has direct and continuing effects on the development of the brain. As such, mobile elements can help explain how this process occurs, and why the effects of even the same environment can differ among individuals (especially given the random nature of mobile elements), but it's only a part of the picture.
Blogging the Backlog
I'm currently sitting on a large stack of magazines and journals that I've been meaning to go through. In the next few weeks I'll be making a concerted effort to get through them -- find what's interesting -- but I've also decided to take this as an opportunity to flex my writing muscles. So I'll be writing up a series of blog posts focusing on the interesting info I pick up in my reading. They'll be shorter than a usual writeup--more of an abstract than a full exploration--but often one of the best ways of figuring out (and remembering) an article is to focus on the big picture.
First up, the March issue of Scientific American.
First up, the March issue of Scientific American.
Tuesday, April 24, 2012
Amazing Grace and Feeling Good
I recently attended a meeting of an Evangelical Christian church with a good friend. This was something completely new for me; I'd grown up in a relatively conservative (personally, not politically) Methodist church, and while Evangelicalism is currently one of the dominant forces in American culture and politics, public perception is obviously different from private practice. Of course I know Evangelicals (and I've been witnessed to probably a dozen times, poor kids) but lately I've been developing a more nuanced understanding of this denomination, thanks in part to the excellent Slacktivist blog, and I was interested to find out what worship means on a more personal level to someone with this belief system.
I took away several things from that service, only a few of which I'm going to touch on here. One thing I realized is that the hype is not necessarily untrue; the service was bombastic and professionally choreographed, with a full band and plenty of AV materials to put up on the huge monitors. (I'm assuming our proximity to Hollywood plays a role in that.)
But when it came down to the actual sermon and the message it was conveying, things started to sound very familiar. The principal theme was the classic redemption story: no matter what you've done or what you think, you can accept God into your heart and be forgiven. You can go from a state of confusion and despondency to a state of confidence. Don't let your brain hold you back; give your heart up to God... And I started to realize that everything, from the goals to the language to the techniques, was remarkably similar to what is found in cognitive behavioral therapy, or CBT.
In CBT, the focus is on solving immediate problems -- unhealthy relationships, lack of confidence, depression, etc. -- by identifying and challenging self-defeating beliefs and changing the associated emotional contexts. The same basic ideas were outlined in the sermon, with some minor variations; where they talked about your "heart," CBT might talk about your emotional reactions; where they talked about your "brain," CBT might talk about self-defeating beliefs; where they talked about God's acceptance, CBT would focus on self-acceptance. The basic religious structure that they were outlining essentially had the form of a therapeutic intervention.
Now, I am definitely not saying there are no differences between Evangelical worship and CBT, nor am I arguing that people subscribe to Evangelical beliefs for the same reason people seek out CBT. I am sure there are those that do, but I am not arguing that they would necessarily achieve the same outcomes whether through the church or through CBT. Instead, this got me thinking about the cultural connections between psychotherapy and religion. Assuming that this parallel between contemporary worship and contemporary psychotherapy is valid, who influenced whom? Is it that the Evangelical church is taking cues (consciously or unconsciously) from the self-help movement? Or is it that this stream of person-focused religious thought influenced the development of CBT? (Was Albert Ellis a religious man? Even if not, religious belief likely permeated his cultural environment.) These ideas are both rather simplistic ideas of causation, and neither is likely to be the whole story; it is far more likely that there has been some back-and-forth through history, both within religious and therapeutic ideas, and ideas external to both.
Psychologists and psychotherapists have long been interested in religion, both as a mental and social phenomenon, and in terms of its therapeutic implications. Psychoanalysts seem to be particularly concerned about this. In his book Psychoanalysis and Religion, Erich Fromm argued that religions can be essentially authoritative or essentially humanistic, and that beliefs stemming from these religions have implications, for good or ill, on human growth and development. (The type of Evangelical Christianity described here would be considered more humanistic.) And, of course, both Freud and Jung wrote extensively on religion and its effects on the human psyche, Freud from a relatively more Christian-centric (though atheistic) perspective, while Jung famously took inspiration from eastern religions. Of course, both men were still raised in a cultural milieu where Christianity was the dominant religious ideology, so it would be interesting to compare therapeutic techniques that have been developed completely outside of this worldview, if any exist.
I took away several things from that service, only a few of which I'm going to touch on here. One thing I realized is that the hype is not necessarily untrue; the service was bombastic and professionally choreographed, with a full band and plenty of AV materials to put up on the huge monitors. (I'm assuming our proximity to Hollywood plays a role in that.)
But when it came down to the actual sermon and the message it was conveying, things started to sound very familiar. The principal theme was the classic redemption story: no matter what you've done or what you think, you can accept God into your heart and be forgiven. You can go from a state of confusion and despondency to a state of confidence. Don't let your brain hold you back; give your heart up to God... And I started to realize that everything, from the goals to the language to the techniques, was remarkably similar to what is found in cognitive behavioral therapy, or CBT.
In CBT, the focus is on solving immediate problems -- unhealthy relationships, lack of confidence, depression, etc. -- by identifying and challenging self-defeating beliefs and changing the associated emotional contexts. The same basic ideas were outlined in the sermon, with some minor variations; where they talked about your "heart," CBT might talk about your emotional reactions; where they talked about your "brain," CBT might talk about self-defeating beliefs; where they talked about God's acceptance, CBT would focus on self-acceptance. The basic religious structure that they were outlining essentially had the form of a therapeutic intervention.
Now, I am definitely not saying there are no differences between Evangelical worship and CBT, nor am I arguing that people subscribe to Evangelical beliefs for the same reason people seek out CBT. I am sure there are those that do, but I am not arguing that they would necessarily achieve the same outcomes whether through the church or through CBT. Instead, this got me thinking about the cultural connections between psychotherapy and religion. Assuming that this parallel between contemporary worship and contemporary psychotherapy is valid, who influenced whom? Is it that the Evangelical church is taking cues (consciously or unconsciously) from the self-help movement? Or is it that this stream of person-focused religious thought influenced the development of CBT? (Was Albert Ellis a religious man? Even if not, religious belief likely permeated his cultural environment.) These ideas are both rather simplistic ideas of causation, and neither is likely to be the whole story; it is far more likely that there has been some back-and-forth through history, both within religious and therapeutic ideas, and ideas external to both.
Psychologists and psychotherapists have long been interested in religion, both as a mental and social phenomenon, and in terms of its therapeutic implications. Psychoanalysts seem to be particularly concerned about this. In his book Psychoanalysis and Religion, Erich Fromm argued that religions can be essentially authoritative or essentially humanistic, and that beliefs stemming from these religions have implications, for good or ill, on human growth and development. (The type of Evangelical Christianity described here would be considered more humanistic.) And, of course, both Freud and Jung wrote extensively on religion and its effects on the human psyche, Freud from a relatively more Christian-centric (though atheistic) perspective, while Jung famously took inspiration from eastern religions. Of course, both men were still raised in a cultural milieu where Christianity was the dominant religious ideology, so it would be interesting to compare therapeutic techniques that have been developed completely outside of this worldview, if any exist.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)